Paper study Assignment: deadline on Thursday March 27th midnight
(copy-pasted from the paper study specification pdf visible in moodle Topic1)
Please upload a pdf strictly structured as follows :
PAGE NUMBER and SIZE:
- MAXIMUM 3 pages where each page strictly adheres to the specifications provided below.
- 1 page = [min: 2500 , max: 3000] characters including spaces (use text editing tools to count characters ; for example this full page without the header has 2855 characters including spaces ). - NO image.
STYLE CONSTRAINTS:
- Do not copy-paste any piece of text from the paper to study unless you make clear it is a citation (with double quotes). - the full reference of the studied paper is the first listed at the beginning of page 3 and is referred to as [0] in page 1 and 2. - use numbered references like this [1] to spare space on pages 1 and 2.
PAGE 1 starts with the AI use statement as a single line (no need to indicate spelling or grammar check tools). It is either the following statement “No GenAI tool has been used to prepare this assignment”, or a single line gathering the publisher, tool and type of use as a list of verbs: summarize, (re)structure, reformulate, compare, understand concept, etc…
Page 1 then focuses on the contributions of the paper, highlighting a selection of key earlier papers [min: 2, max: 4] to show how the paper exploits them/ compares to them. At the bottom of the page, provide a 1-2 sentence(s) summary for each of the selected earlier papers. Follow this style : Paper [1] compares the effectiveness of.... with.... etc....
PAGE 2 includes your analysis of the citations of this paper by others (e.g. who, why, when) ; first indicate the tool you used and the total number of citations you found. Then make a selection of papers (min: 5, max: 8) to highlight a VARIETY of cases about how the field has evolved since the paper appeared in publication. Include the most cited paper among this selection. The VARIETY criteria will be assessed as follow: - no more than 1 survey/review/book - at least 2 references from other authors, different from those of [0] - time range of the chosen references should spread between [0] publication year and now ; let's note N the number of years since the publication of [0], then a maximum of half of the references should be in the N/2 years that followed the publication of [0]. IMPORTANT: conclude PAGE 2 with an explicit subsection "Conclusion" stating your own viewpoint on the past and future evolution of the topic.
PAGE 3 lists the paper references used for pages 1 and 2 ; it starts with the studied paper reference labelled as [0]. For each numbered reference provide the paper title, publication year, author list, source of publication (conference, journal, book), publisher, volume and number (for journal) or chapter (for book), page numbers, and DOI (or a link to the internet location where you found the paper) so that we can find it easily.
(copy-pasted from the paper study specification pdf visible in moodle Topic1)
Please upload a pdf strictly structured as follows :
PAGE NUMBER and SIZE:
- MAXIMUM 3 pages where each page strictly adheres to the specifications provided below.
- 1 page = [min: 2500 , max: 3000] characters including spaces (use text editing tools to count characters ; for example this full page without the header has 2855 characters including spaces ). - NO image.
STYLE CONSTRAINTS:
- Do not copy-paste any piece of text from the paper to study unless you make clear it is a citation (with double quotes). - the full reference of the studied paper is the first listed at the beginning of page 3 and is referred to as [0] in page 1 and 2. - use numbered references like this [1] to spare space on pages 1 and 2.
PAGE 1 starts with the AI use statement as a single line (no need to indicate spelling or grammar check tools). It is either the following statement “No GenAI tool has been used to prepare this assignment”, or a single line gathering the publisher, tool and type of use as a list of verbs: summarize, (re)structure, reformulate, compare, understand concept, etc…
Page 1 then focuses on the contributions of the paper, highlighting a selection of key earlier papers [min: 2, max: 4] to show how the paper exploits them/ compares to them. At the bottom of the page, provide a 1-2 sentence(s) summary for each of the selected earlier papers. Follow this style : Paper [1] compares the effectiveness of.... with.... etc....
PAGE 2 includes your analysis of the citations of this paper by others (e.g. who, why, when) ; first indicate the tool you used and the total number of citations you found. Then make a selection of papers (min: 5, max: 8) to highlight a VARIETY of cases about how the field has evolved since the paper appeared in publication. Include the most cited paper among this selection. The VARIETY criteria will be assessed as follow: - no more than 1 survey/review/book - at least 2 references from other authors, different from those of [0] - time range of the chosen references should spread between [0] publication year and now ; let's note N the number of years since the publication of [0], then a maximum of half of the references should be in the N/2 years that followed the publication of [0]. IMPORTANT: conclude PAGE 2 with an explicit subsection "Conclusion" stating your own viewpoint on the past and future evolution of the topic.
PAGE 3 lists the paper references used for pages 1 and 2 ; it starts with the studied paper reference labelled as [0]. For each numbered reference provide the paper title, publication year, author list, source of publication (conference, journal, book), publisher, volume and number (for journal) or chapter (for book), page numbers, and DOI (or a link to the internet location where you found the paper) so that we can find it easily.
Sorry, no guest users are allowed to access this plugin. Please login.
