review with no feedback

review with no feedback

by Nagyung Kim -
Number of replies: 2

Hello.
How should I write down the rebuttal if one of the reviews has given only positive feedback? Should I still divide my rebuttal into three parts? If so, what should I say as a rebuttal where I have none?

In reply to Nagyung Kim

Re: review with no feedback

by Nagyung Kim -
Hello.
I uploaded part 3 without writing back to one of them (which only gave positive feedback) assuming that it is impossible to write a **rebuttal** for it, and as I was anxious about uploading it too late. However, would it be possible to get the answer to my previous question so that I can edit my rebuttal, if necessary?
Thank you.
In reply to Nagyung Kim

Re: review with no feedback

by Haoqian Zhang -
We understand that this may happen. In this case, you will still need to write it in three parts and do your best according to the instructions.

Haoqian